which year was the best?

[Crucified Coma]

2003
Suffocation, Necrophagist (Germany), Devourment, Sublime Cadaveric Decomposition (France), Aborted (Belgium), Abuse (Canada), Severed Savior, Soils of Fate (Sweden), Dying Fetus, Brodequin, Foetopsy, Drogheda, Saprogenic, Pyrexia, Retch, Circle of Dead Children, Malignancy, Mortal Decay, Commit Suicide, Skinless, Goratory, Internal Bleeding, Incinerate, Nemo, Lust of Decay, Putrid Pile, Wasteform, Psychotogen, Suture, Anoxia, Malamor, Scumbitch, Severed Head, Spinefed, Artery Eruption

2004
Repulsion, Exhumed, Rotten Sound (Finland), Macabre, The Red Chord, Leng Tch'e (Belgium), Pig Destroyer, Phobia, Inhume (Netherlands), Vomit Remnants (Japan), Rompeprop (Netherlands), Bile (Netherlands), Arsis, Misery Index, Dehumanized, Profanity (Germany), Internal Suffering (Colombia), Malignancy, Neuraxis (Canada), Mortal Decay, Circle of Dead Children, Man Must Die (Scotland), Brodequin, Fleshtized, Swarm of the Lotus, Brainwash (Italy), Bodies in the Gears of the Apparatus, Biolich

2005
Immolation, Cryptopsy (Canada), General Surgery (Sweden), Regurgitate (Sweden), Abscess, Impaled, Birdflesh (Sweden), Rotten Sound (Finland), Wormed (Spain), Gronibard (France), Aborted (Belgium), Pig Destroyer, Misery Index, Leng Tch'e (Belgium), Ghoul, Lord Gore, Bodies Lay Broken, Splatterhouse, XXX Maniak, Despised Icon (Canada), Kill the Client, Ion Dissonance (Canada), Guttural Secrete, Magrudergrind, Warscars (France), Prophecy, Amoebic Dysentery, Screaming Afterbith

2006
Dismember (Sweden), Vital Remains, Pungent Stench (Austria), Haemorrhage (Spain), Necrophagist (Germany), Demilich (Finland), Cattle Decapitation, Anata (Sweden), Machetazo (Spain), Severe Torture (Netherlands), Unholy Grave (Japan), Butcher ABC (Japan), Disfear (Sweden), Rompeprop (Netherlands), Skinless, Gorgasm, Yacoepsae (Germany), Municipal Waste, Embalmer, Sayyadina (Sweden), Alarum (Australia), Cliteater (Netherlands), Sanitys Dawn (Germany), Mucupurlulent (Germany), Catheter, Total Fucking Destruction, Cenotaph (Turkey), Electro Quarterstaff (Canada), Magrudergrind, Quills, Embryonic Cryptopathia

[The Blenderfist]

04 was the most fun I had ever had..........

but 06 was in a good club, with alot of good people hanging out, and alot of good bands.......its tough to pick one.

[Crucified Coma]

I haven't gone yet, but based on the lineups, I went with 2005.

[Azathoth]

2003 with 2005 not too far behind.

[Ripper]

I had to go with 2006 cause it was my first time there, just wished I could have gone the previous years but I'll be back again next year.

[dr0ne]

A tie between 04 and 06.

[DE]

05 because of
Immolation,
Cryptopsy
General Surgery
Regurgitate
Impaled
Birdflesh
Rotten Sound
Wormed
Gronibard
Aborted
Pig Destroyer
Misery Index
Leng Tch'e
Ghoul
Lord Gore
Bodies Lay Broken
Splatterhouse
XXX Maniak
Kill the Client
Guttural Secrete
Magrudergrind
Amoebic Dysentery

[tck!]

I haven't gone yet, but based on the lineups, I went with 2005.

[tenaciousg]

04, 05, 06 are excellent

06 but barely

[ANAL WARFARE]

2005 because of Birdflesh, General Surgery, Ghoul, Wormed, Rotten Sound, and Splatterhouse. i kick myself every time i listen to Immolation for leaving after General Surgery ended. i wanted to stay so bad but my feet were shot. im sure they played Rival The Eminent, No Jesus No Beast, and Here In After and that makes me hurt even more

[Crucified Coma]

Eh, Immolation are one of the worst live bands in existence.

[Azathoth]

Immolation are one of the best live bands in existence.

Fixed it for you.

[Crucified Coma]

Nah, not even close. They're boring as fuck.

[TURDS]

04! i cant believe i saw repulsion!!!!!!!!! and immolation are no even close to being the best live band!!
BRING THESE BANDS PLEASE!!!

CBT
TU CARNE
MALIGNANT TUMOR
FLESHPARADE
DEAD HORSE reunion
BENUMB
ahumado granujo last show

[The Blenderfist]

I will say this....in 05 Regurgitate totally onwed my ass...I thought they were the best band at day 1

[CrackHeadCarianne]

i would have killed to go to '05 :(

[Azathoth]

Nah, not even close. They're boring as fuck.

Yeah you're right. Pointless, monotonous gore bands are so entertaining.

[Crucified Coma]

Yeah you're right. Pointless, monotonous gore bands are so entertaining.
I'm not sure who you're referring to, but you're probably right.

A lot of death metal bands are amazing live, but Immolation aren't one of them.

[Azathoth]

Right over your head. :)

[Crucified Coma]

I know what you were saying, but I agreed. The most monotonous "gore" band IS probably still better than Immolation. That's how much they suck. Even people I know who like them have said they're boring as hell live.

[Azathoth]

Really? Because it doesn't seem like you do. Otherwise I don't think you'd agree. But it's no big deal.

[Crucified Coma]

Otherwise I don't think you'd agree.
Nah, I still do.

[Azathoth]

Nah, I still do.

Well at least we both agree you have shitty taste in metal.

[SculptedCold]

Never been, but as for lineup I vote 2003 hands-down.

I saw Immolation once, but I wasn't familiar with them at the time. What I do remember is that it sounded like a shitty mess; couldn't make out any of the instruments or anything, regardless of how badly or goodly they played.

[Azathoth]

I saw them last night, third time I've seen them, and can say they sounded flawless live. Their instruments were much easier to discern and cleaner than many other death metal bands. AMAZING show.

[Huge Cock]

hey guyz just wanted to let u know that if u don't like the type of music i do then i will totally fucking post a retort saying why your music of choice is gay BE FUCKING PREPARED

[ANAL WARFARE]

i still have never seen Immolation. they never play here or anywhere ive lived. the one time i get the chance, i puss out because my dogs were barking from standing 12 hours in a row. i cant imagine them being boring live. but im a huge fan and realize just how much heavier they are than pretty much anything. listen to Failure For Gods in its entirety and tell me im wrong.

[HeReTiK]

2005 cause of XXX Maniak. :emot-nod:

[TURDS]

by the looks of it 2007 will be the best..........easily

[john]

2006 is gonna be insane... It'll be hard to beat Rompeprop and Haemorrhage, though. Looks great so far. Tons of grind!!!

[Crucified Coma]

2005 cause of XXX Maniak. :emot-nod:
Nothing involving Jason is the best. NOTHING!

[TURDS]

oh ya!!!! i forgot XXX was even there...REGURG and Gen Surg owned that year!

[Shooter McFatass]

Nothing involving Jason is the best. NOTHING!

Whys that?

[deathmetaljohn]

xxx maniak killed in my opinion and it seemed like jason was a pretty cool guy when i talked to them after the set

[Crucified Coma]

Jason likes men. It's a fact. He comes on to me on a daily basis.

(look for his "advice column" on SMN to be launched next week)

[deathmetaljohn]

well than tell him your not interested lol hes still got a killer band

[dr0ne]

He is a pretty faggy dude, he once sent me a picture of him with some a tranny :(.

[deathmetaljohn]

that doesent change the fact that xxx maniak is a sick fuckin band

[dr0ne]

lol we're all kidding here guy, we're both XXX fans and talk to the guy regularly....



..but he really did try to fuck me once, that wasn't a lie. :(

[deathmetaljohn]

hahah ohhh ok i was wondering what the fuck that was about i couldent imagine him being gay

[Crucified Coma]

Ya never know. ;)